Plenitude vs Naturgy
A detailed head-to-head comparison covering rates, typical bills, pros & cons, and features to help you decide which is better for your home.
Our Verdict
Overall Winner: Lowest Typical Bill
For a typical Spanish household (3.6kW Potencia, 300kWh monthly usage), Plenitude is the cheaper option. Their Fácil Luz tariff results in an estimated monthly bill of €66.18 (including taxes). This compares to Naturgy's best option (Tarifa Noche) at €67.42 per month.
* Assumption: 3.6 kW contracted power, 300 kWh monthly usage (20% peak, 30% flat, 50% off-peak), including 21% IVA, 5.11% Electricity Tax, and ~€1 meter rental.
Best Flat Rate
Plenitude wins here. Their flat rate is 0.097296 €/kWh compared to Naturgy's 0.112 €/kWh.
Best Time-of-Use Rate
Naturgy is the only provider offering a fixed 3-period time-of-use rate.
Scorecard Comparison
| Metric (1-10) | Plenitude | Naturgy |
|---|---|---|
| Price Competitiveness | 8 | 7 |
| Solar Suitability | 7 | 6 |
| EV Suitability | 6 | 5 |
| Simplicity | 8 | 7 |
| Customer Service | 7 | 5 |
| Transparency | 8 | 6 |
Full Head-to-Head Comparison
Plenitude
Pros
- Energía 100% renovable certificada
- Tarifas de precio fijo sencillas y estables
- Respaldo financiero del grupo Eni
- Sin permanencia ni penalizaciones
Cons
- Modelo de atención al cliente tradicional
- Precios que pueden ser superiores a discounters de nicho
- Enfoque principal en planes de tarifa fija
Available Tariffs
Fácil Luz
Naturgy
Pros
- Ideal para combinar Gas y Luz
- Tarifas sencillas y transparentes
- Empresa muy estable
- Servicio técnico experimentado
Cons
- Menos agresivos en precios de solo electricidad
- Herramientas digitales básicas frente a Octopus
- Sensación de gran corporación
Available Tariffs
Tarifa Por Uso Luz
Tarifa Noche
Find the absolute best supplier for your home
Don't rely on typical profiles. Upload your real bill and our AI will calculate exactly which supplier is cheaper for your actual energy usage.
Analyze My Bill Now